- Customers
Morning Mugs
Beyond the Feed: How Morning Mugs Used Toast IQ Grow to Increase Sales from Email & SMS by 8x
Business type
Products used
Location
Baltimore, MD

When Tyler DellaRatta opened Morning Mugs in 2021, he wanted to create a memorable coffee shop experience for his guests. These days, that experience shows up everywhere – with an always-on color guessing game promotion, in the shop’s retro-inspired merch, or with viral specials like their dot cake latte. Morning Mugs made the switch to Toast in 2024 to support their growth ambitions. More recently, they are using Toast IQ Grow – which includes Toast’s AI marketing agent backed by a dedicated marketing expert – to complement their social storytelling and help turn untapped channels like email and SMS into real sales drivers.
Challenge
A POS Partner for the Present and Future
Tyler worked in tech sales before opening Morning Mugs, and he brings that same instinct to the business: pay attention to what's actually working, and don't stay loyal to a system just because it's familiar. That approach is what eventually brought Morning Mugs to Toast.
While Square was not posing any pressing issues, Tyler started to notice tradeoffs as he was introduced to Toast and started to compare.
“At the time I had opened a second location. Our Toast sales rep understood how we were trying to scale, and we saw that switching would make things easier as we grew."
Tyer DellaRatta
Owner
Solution
Managing Restaurant Operations All-in-One
Tyler acknowledges that while Toast can sometimes cost more than competitors, it’s a tradeoff he is willing to make for quality.
“For me, I live in Toast. I don’t have to log into seven different places or worry about whether this is connected to that – it’s all in one place. There’s so much for business owners to deal with day to day. I am looking to simplify wherever I can – and I am willing to pay for it."
Tyer DellaRatta
Owner
That consolidation shows up in smaller ways, too. “We do less and less duplicate work and reporting in Excel because we can manage everything in Toast,” he says.
Everyday operational tasks take less time, which makes a difference for an owner who's also running the register, designing merchandise, and posting on social media.
Turning an Untapped Customer List into Sales
Marketing at Morning Mugs has historically leaned heavily on social media, with Tyler and his team posting new content every day of the week. That focus has built a strong brand identity, but also left gaps in their marketing strategy.
Customer information was being captured through Morning Mugs’ loyalty program – which has amassed over 17,000 members – but this group did not receive any targeted or regular communications.
“We collect all of this information, whether it’s through loyalty or other programs, and we weren’t utilizing it – which was a mistake. As the owner, I would always come back to this task to send out marketing emails, but there were always other priorities that came first,” says Tyler.
When Tyler learned about Toast IQ Grow, he jumped at the opportunity to delegate some of the marketing work to a team and tool he already trusted.
“If I need to go out and hire an email marketing contractor I can go to [gig platforms], but it takes a lot of time to get them up and running. Toast IQ Grow brings me someone who knows the platform and works with other businesses like mine, so it was easy to get on board with."
Tyer DellaRatta
Owner
After getting started, Tyler wasn’t chasing an immediate return so much as consistency he could count on – the belief that steady visibility compounds into sales over time, even before the dashboard proves it. “At the end of the day, showing up in someone’s inbox is what’s most important, and Toast IQ Grow is making that happen,” says Tyler.
While ROI wasn’t necessarily what Tyler cared about in the near-term – it was still delivered. Looking year over year, Morning Mugs has seen an 8x increase in their marketing-attributed sales from email and SMS* since using Toast IQ Grow.
Results
Growing Morning Mugs, One Cup at a Time
Having been voted Best Coffee Shop in Baltimore by Baltimore Magazine for the last five consecutive years – it’s safe to say that Morning Mugs is delivering on their promise of memorable experiences.
For Tyler and the team, Toast has been more than just a set of tools to help them get there. “With Toast, I feel supported. If I want something or think something can be better, I'm going to speak up about it, and I've never been shut down. That personal touch is really what separates Toast for me,” says Tyler.
In the last two years, their team has used:
Toast POS & Reporting: To keep tabs on growing food, beverage, and merchandise sales in one place.
Toast Loyalty: To build and reach a list of over 17,000 returning customers.
Toast IQ Grow: Delivered the consistent marketing push behind a $100,000 year over year increase in marketing-attributed sales from email, SMS, Loyalty, and Gift Cards**.
“Consistency at the end of the day is what makes a business either good or great – and Toast plays a big role in that. As long as we can deliver the same consistent, incredible experience and everything on the back end is simplified, I know I'm going to be happy, my team is going to be happy, and the business has a higher probability of success."
Tyer DellaRatta
Owner
FAQs
Morning Mugs’ previous POS provider worked well operationally, but Morning Mugs' owner felt that Toast could be the best partner to support as they planned for more growth.
